Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza
What to get
The menu centers on authentic New York style pizza, including classic cheese slices. For a hearty meal, the various sub sandwiches are a standout option.food_potoo
What's the vibe
The space feels like a classic, no-frills neighborhood staple where the focus remains entirely on the food. It maintains a reliable, old-school atmosphere that has clearly served the local community for decades.ambiance_potoo
What people are saying
Visitors frequently highlight the authenticity of the New York style pizza, noting that the flavor remains consistent and high-quality even after many years.reviews_potoo
Details
About
A local fixture since 1972, this shop has built a loyal following by perfecting the art of the New York style slice. It has remained a consistent destination for generations of families in the area.story_potoo