The grandma pie is a standout with its crunchy, buttery crust, hearty sauce, and fresh basil. You should also try the pasta with vodka sauce or one of the many specialty white pies.food_potoo
The space has a casual, neighborhood feel with a wall-mounted NYTimes article that highlights its local recognition. It feels like a straightforward, unpretentious spot where friendly staff welcome you in.ambiance_potoo
Reviewers frequently highlight the excellence of the grandma pie, specifically noting its crunchy, buttery crust and hearty sauce. The white pies and pasta with vodka sauce also receive high marks from locals.reviews_potoo
This spot earned significant local recognition after being named one of the top 25 slices in NYC by the NYTimes in 2024. It has become a reliable neighborhood staple for those seeking a classic New York slice.story_potoo