One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Fine American diningshort_description_potoo

4.3(9,261)

$$$$

Closed now

Opens 5:15 PMGreenwich Village

One if by Land, Two if by Sea is an upscale American restaurant defined by its romantic, historic atmosphere and elegant service. long_description_potoo

Featured by

The fireplace is lit in winter and is a centerpiece of the room, creating a sublime atmosphere where one can easily imagine a time of horses trotting along on the cobblestoned side street.

What to get

Consider the Chef's Tasting Menu, which includes Lobster Consommé, Tuna Crudo, Poached Halibut, and Beef Wellington, finishing with Chocolate Soufflé. Alternatively, the Bar Menu offers options like Escargot, Seared Foie Gras, and Winter Truffle Raviolo.food

What's the vibe

Stepping into this 18th-century carriage house feels like crashing a lavish wedding dinner, complete with glowing fireplaces and black-tie waiters. The bi-level dining room, with its brick walls, high ceilings, and arched windows overlooking gardens, sets a distinctly romantic, old-world tone.ambiance

What people are saying

Patrons highlight the extraordinary Black Truffle Dinner and the incredible, attentive service. Many longtime visitors return to enjoy the timeless ambiance and the quality of the fine dining experience.reviews_potoo

4.3

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

9,261 reviews

Details

Greenwich Village

17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014

Closed now

• Opens 5:15 PM

oneifbyland.com

+1 212-255-8649

About

This historic carriage house, once owned by Aaron Burr, served as his stable before his infamous duel with Alexander Hamilton. It later became a stop on the Underground Railroad, a silent movie house, and even a house of ill-repute.story