Ms. Apples Crab Shack
What to get
The menu focuses on fresh, locally caught seafood, specifically live crabs that arrive fresh from the fishermen each morning. The selection is driven by what is available from the daily catch.food_potoo
What's the vibe
Walking inside feels like entering an organized chaos typical of a local bait shop, with open bins of live crabs visible. The atmosphere is unpretentious and purely functional, centered around the daily catch.ambiance_potoo
What people are saying
Reviewers highlight the freshness of the locally caught seafood and the authentic, bait-shop atmosphere. Many note that the daily selection depends on the morning's catch, making it a true destination for fresh crabs.reviews_potoo
Details
About
A local staple since 1991, this spot has spent decades building a loyal following by providing the island with whatever the local fishermen bring in each day. The availability of the seafood is dictated entirely by the morning's haul.story_potoo